Jesús María vs San Isidro: better rental investment? (2026)
n = 1,638 Airbnb listings · 1,392 sale listings · source: urbania.pe + airroi · as of 2026-11-15 · methodology →
Jesús María wins on the number that matters for a long-term let, and it wins while costing less to get in: about 4.8% net against San Isidro's roughly 4.4%. That long-term figure already subtracts property tax, arbitrios, rental income tax and a 3% vacancy allowance. It does not subtract mantenimiento, because in a Lima long-term let the tenant pays that, not you. You self-manage, so no fee comes off either.
The entry price is where the gap gets real. Jesús María sells for a median of about $2,110 per m2; San Isidro for about $2,510. Per square metre that is roughly 15.5% cheaper, or about $394 less. On a 70 m2 reference flat the asking prices land near $147,690 and $175,730 respectively. You are paying less per square metre for a higher net yield, which is not the usual trade in this city.
Airbnb flips the ranking, narrowly. Gross, Jesús María runs about 7.1% against San Isidro's roughly 7.5%. Note what the short-let figure subtracts: the platform fee, host-paid utilities and internet, income tax, mantenimiento (the host pays it here, no guest reimburses them), property tax and arbitrios. Neither side carries furnishing, cleaning or management fees in these numbers, so treat both as optimistic on that front.
My pick is Jesús María, on the long-term let. You give up the San Isidro address and whatever cachet a tenant pays for it, and you take on a district that is workmanlike rather than glossy. In exchange you buy in cheaper per square metre and collect a higher net yield. San Isidro only makes sense if you believe the short-let premium holds and you are willing to run the flat yourself to capture it — and the gross gap there is thin.
Two caveats. These figures are approximate and held steady between real moves, so the tables on the page may show slightly different exact values. And the data here is thin on the things that decide a short-let in practice: occupancy, nightly rates and seasonality are not in front of me, so I will not pretend to rank the two on them. Not investment advice.