PeruYield
● 2026-11-15
Sale and rent listings were re-scraped on 2026-11-15 — asking prices, that day. Airbnb figures are a monthly aggregate for 2026-11: nightly rates and occupancy measured across that month, not that day. Lima only, and asking prices throughout — no transaction data exists for this market.

Jesús María vs Magdalena: better rental investment? (2026)

n = 1,162 Airbnb listings · 611 sale listings · source: urbania.pe + airroi · as of 2026-11-15 · methodology →

Magdalena edges it on long-term net yield, about 5.1% against roughly 4.8% for Jesús María, and that is the whole of the gap. If you are buying a flat to hand to a tenant and forget about, the difference is not worth agonising over. You are choosing on price and on how easily you can sell, not on the headline number.

On price Magdalena is the dearer of the two: a median of about $2,146 per m2 against about $2,110 in Jesús María, roughly 1.1% more, or about $23 per m2. On a 70 m2 flat that is a real but modest sum. Jesús María is the cheaper way in, and the long-term yield it gives up for that is small.

The Airbnb side flips the order, and only just. Jesús María runs about 7.1% gross against Magdalena's roughly 7.0%. That is a rounding error dressed up as an advantage, and I would not move a purchase decision on it. Note what the short-let figure has to carry: the platform fee, utilities and internet you pay as host, income tax, mantenimiento, property tax and arbitrios. The long-term figure subtracts property tax, arbitrios, rental income tax and a vacancy allowance; the tenant pays mantenimiento in a Lima long let, so that cost does not touch the landlord. Both figures assume you self-manage.

So the pick depends on what you are actually doing. If you want the simpler holding and the slightly better net yield, Magdalena. If you want the lower entry price and a hair more short-let upside, Jesús María. Neither is a mistake at these numbers, and anyone telling you one clearly beats the other on yield is overselling a gap of a few tenths of a point.

Where the data is thin: these are approximate medians and steady-state yields, not transaction-level records, and they will not tell you about the specific building, the tenant you get, or how deep the resale market is on your street. Go look at the blocks yourself before you wire anything.

Lima Property Investor Weekly · free

The typical Lima Airbnb earns less than a long-term tenant. The top quarter earns more.

Not a hunch — we price every listed apartment in eight districts both ways, self-managed, after tax, HOA and real occupancy. One email a week: what moved, which listings the numbers actually favour, and where the consensus looks wrong.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.