3-bedroom apartment in Magdalena, Lima: yields (2026)
n = 467 Airbnb listings · 327 sale listings · source: urbania.pe + airroi · as of 2026-11-15 · methodology →
A 3-bed in Magdalena is a near-tie on paper: about 6.2% gross long-term against roughly 5.9% on Airbnb. That is the whole story in one line, and it points at the tenant. The short-let only makes sense if you want the flat for yourself part of the year, because the numbers do not pay you for the extra work.
Be clear about what these figures are. Both are gross, so neither has had property tax, arbitrios or income tax taken off yet. The long-term figure also sits before a vacancy allowance, and the Airbnb figure sits before the platform fee, the utilities and internet you pay as host, and mantenimiento — which on a short let falls to you, while in a long-term let the tenant carries it. Once those are subtracted the two drift further apart in the tenant's favour, though I will not put a number on it here.
Who does this suit? Someone who wants a three-bedroom unit working quietly in the background and does not need the flat empty for a month each year. The owner self-manages in this model on both sides, so the honest comparison is not 6.2% against 5.9% — it is a tenant who stays for a year against a calendar you have to keep filling.
The case for Airbnb is thin at this size. A three-bedroom short let in Magdalena competes with family-sized supply and needs a guest mix that most owners never quite assemble. If you are buying to let and nothing else, take the long-term let and stop thinking about it.
Caveats, plainly. These are approximate gross yields held steady between real moves, so the tables on the page may show a slightly different exact value. They are not a forecast, and they are not investment advice.