San Miguel vs Surco: better rental investment? (2026)
n = 1,941 Airbnb listings · 2,294 sale listings · source: urbania.pe + airroi · as of 2026-11-15 · methodology →
San Miguel edges it, but not on the number most people came for. Long-term net yield is about 5.0% against Surco's about 4.8% - a gap of roughly 0.3 points, which is noise. You are not choosing between these two on the headline yield. You are choosing on what you pay to get in and what the flat can do when a tenant is not in it.
On price San Miguel is the cheaper entry: about $1,750 per m2 against about $1,790 in Surco, roughly 3.6% less, or about $64 per m2. On a 70 m2 flat that is the difference between about $122,650 and about $126,420. Modest money, but it is real money, and it is the one place where the two districts separate cleanly.
The Airbnb side leans the same way. Gross, San Miguel runs about 6.7% against Surco's about 6.0%. Treat that as a gross figure and nothing more: the Airbnb number subtracts the platform fee, host-paid utilities and internet, income tax, mantenimiento, property tax and arbitrios, and the owner self-manages. The long-term figure subtracts property tax, arbitrios, rental income tax and a 3% vacancy allowance; the tenant pays mantenimiento there, not you. Neither figure carries furnishing, cleaning or a management fee, because in this model you do those yourself.
So the pick is San Miguel, on the cheaper square metre and the thicker short-let ceiling, with the honest caveat that the long-term case is a near-tie and I would not sell Surco to you on yield. What Surco buys is liquidity and a deeper resale pool - the kind of thing my wife and I argue about over lunch and that no table on this page settles. If you want to exit in a hurry, that matters more than 0.3 points.
Where the data is thin: these are approximate medians and steady-state yields, held between real moves, and the tables on the page may show a slightly different exact value. They say nothing about your specific building, its administration, or how well you actually run a short let - and most owners do not run one well. Not investment advice.