San Isidro vs Surco: better rental investment? (2026)
n = 1,763 Airbnb listings · 2,901 sale listings · source: urbania.pe + airroi · as of 2026-11-15 · methodology →
Surco wins on the long-term let, and it is not close on price: roughly 4.8% net against San Isidro's 4.4%, for a square metre that costs about 28.8% less. If you are buying to hand a flat to a tenant and forget about it, that is the whole argument in one line.
The entry cost is the part people underestimate. San Isidro trades around $2,510 per m2, Surco around $1,795 — roughly $727 per m2 apart. On a typical 70 m2 flat that is the difference between about $175,730 and about $126,420. You are paying well over a hundred thousand dollars more to earn a thinner yield in San Isidro. That is the uncomfortable half, and it does not go away because the address sounds better.
Airbnb flips the ranking. Gross, San Isidro runs about 7.2% against Surco's about 6.0%, so the expensive district earns its keep only if you actually run the short-let well. And the Airbnb figure subtracts the platform fee, host-paid utilities and internet, income tax, mantenimiento, property tax and arbitrios — the host carries mantenimiento here because no guest reimburses it. The long-term figure subtracts property tax, arbitrios, rental income tax and a 3% vacancy allowance, and leaves mantenimiento to the tenant. Both assume you self-manage; neither accounts for furnishing, cleaning or a management fee, so treat the short-let number as the more optimistic of the two.
My pick is Surco. You give up the prestige address and the higher gross short-let number, and you take the better net yield on a cheaper square metre with a tenant paying mantenimiento. San Isidro only makes sense if you are confident you can run a short-let near the top of the market — and most owners do not.
One caveat: these are approximations held steady between real moves, and the tables on the page may show slightly different exact values. The long-term figures are net of the costs named above; the short-let figures are gross of your own labour. Not investment advice.