San Isidro vs San Miguel: better rental investment? (2026)
n = 2,064 Airbnb listings · 1,609 sale listings · source: urbania.pe + airroi · as of 2026-11-15 · methodology →
San Miguel wins on the long-term let, and it is not close on price: roughly 5.0% net against San Isidro's about 4.4%, for a median near $1,752 per m2 against about $2,510. You are paying about 30.6% less per square metre, roughly $777 less, to collect a higher net yield. That is the whole case, and it holds up.
Both figures are net of what a Lima landlord actually pays. The long-term figure subtracts property tax, arbitrios, rental income tax and a 3% vacancy allowance; the tenant covers mantenimiento, so the landlord does not. The owner self-manages on both sides. What the long-term figure does not subtract is furnishing, cleaning or a management fee, because the model does not carry them.
On Airbnb the order flips: San Isidro runs about 7.5% gross against San Miguel's roughly 6.7%. The Airbnb figure subtracts the platform fee, host-paid utilities and internet, income tax, mantenimiento (the host pays it here, with no guest reimbursing them), property tax and arbitrios. Note that this is gross, before the long-term costs above, and the owner still self-manages. A short-let in either district is a job, not a passive line.
So the pick depends on what you want to do with your weekends. If you want a tenant and a quiet ledger, San Miguel gives you the better net yield on a cheaper entry price. If you want to run a short-let and believe you can beat the gross figures, San Isidro is where the nightly money is, but you are paying a premium per square metre for it and doing the work yourself.
The honest caveat: these are approximate, held steady between real moves, and the tables on the page may show slightly different exact values. The long-term gap is thin enough that a bad tenant or a long vacancy in San Miguel erases it. I would still take San Miguel for a long-term hold, and I would only take San Isidro if I were committed to the short-let. Not investment advice.