Magdalena vs Surco: better rental investment? (2026)
n = 1,287 Airbnb listings · 2,120 sale listings · source: urbania.pe + airroi · as of 2026-11-15 · methodology →
Magdalena edges it on the numbers, but not by enough to make the decision for you: about 5.1% net long-term against Surco's roughly 4.8%. That is a gap of about 0.3 points, which is noise in a market where the tenant mix and the building matter more than the district average. If you are buying for the coupon alone, neither district is worth paying a premium for.
The price is where these two actually part. Magdalena trades at a median of about $2,204 per m2; Surco at about $1,795. Surco is roughly 17.8% cheaper per square metre, about $389 less on the same square metre. For a foreign buyer wiring money in, that is the whole argument in one line: you are paying up for Magdalena and getting a yield that is, for practical purposes, the same.
On short lets the gap widens a little. Magdalena runs about 7.0% gross on Airbnb against Surco's roughly 6.0%. The Airbnb figure subtracts the platform fee, host-paid utilities and internet, income tax, mantenimiento, property tax and arbitrios, and assumes you self-manage. The long-term figure subtracts property tax, arbitrios, rental income tax and a 3% vacancy allowance; the tenant pays mantenimiento in a Lima long-term let. Neither figure accounts for furnishing or fit-out, and neither accounts for cleaning and turnover on the short-let side. Those come out of your pocket before you see a peso.
So the pick depends on what you are actually buying. If you want the least work and the most predictable cash flow, Surco at the lower entry price is the more sensible buy: you give up a sliver of yield and keep the capital. If you are prepared to run a short let yourself and believe you can hold near that 7.0% gross in Magdalena, the upside is there, but you are paying roughly 17.8% more per square metre to chase it, and the long-term yield does not justify the premium on its own.
One caveat: these are district medians and averages, and the spread within each district is wider than the gap between them. Treat the figures as a starting filter, not a verdict. I would look at specific buildings and specific streets before committing either way. Not investment advice.