Magdalena vs San Miguel: better rental investment? (2026)
n = 1,588 Airbnb listings · 828 sale listings · source: urbania.pe + airroi · as of 2026-11-15 · methodology →
On the headline long-term yield these two are a coin flip: Magdalena about 5.1%, San Miguel about 5.0%. If you are buying to let to a resident tenant, the number that should decide it is not the yield, it is the entry price — and there San Miguel is roughly 19.6% cheaper per square metre, about $428/m² less, at a median near $1,752/m² against Magdalena's near $2,146/m².
So the honest framing for a foreign buyer is this: you are paying Magdalena's premium for a yield that is, in practice, the same. The long-term figure is net — it subtracts property tax, arbitrios, rental income tax and a 3% vacancy allowance, and it does not subtract mantenimiento because in a Lima long-term let the tenant carries that. The owner self-manages. On those terms the two districts land in the same place, and one of them asks far more capital to get there.
Airbnb does not rescue Magdalena's case. On gross short-let returns Magdalena runs about 7.0% against San Miguel's about 6.7% — a gap of roughly 0.3 points, which is thin. The Airbnb figure subtracts the platform fee, host-paid utilities and internet, income tax, mantenimiento (the host pays it here), property tax and arbitrios. Neither figure subtracts furnishing, cleaning or management, so treat both as gross-of-those and budget for them yourself.
My pick is San Miguel, and the reason is price and the thinner downside, not the yield. You buy in cheaper per square metre, the long-term net is effectively identical, and the short-let upside is close enough that a well-run flat in either district can beat a badly run one in the other. Magdalena is the more expensive way to earn the same rent — pay the premium only if you specifically want that address and believe it holds its resale value better, which the numbers here do not prove either way.
Two caveats, stated plainly. The yields are close enough that I would not call a winner on them — the data is too thin to separate 5.1% from 5.0% with confidence, and small differences in your building, your tenant and your vacancy will swamp the district gap. And none of this is investment advice; it is a reading of the price and yield figures, not a forecast.