Magdalena vs San Isidro: better rental investment? (2026)
n = 1,410 Airbnb listings · 1,435 sale listings · source: urbania.pe + airroi · as of 2026-11-15 · methodology →
Magdalena takes the long-term investor's case on both lines that matter: about 5.1% net against San Isidro's roughly 4.4%, and a median near $2,200 per m2 against about $2,510. That is roughly 13.8% cheaper per square metre, or about $349 less. You are not paying a premium for the higher yield here; you are paying less and getting more of it.
The long-term figure subtracts property tax, arbitrios, rental income tax and a 3% vacancy allowance. It does not subtract mantenimiento, because on a Lima long-term let the tenant carries that. The owner self-manages in this model, so no management fee is taken off either side. What you give up for the extra yield is the address: San Isidro is the more expensive district, and buyers pay for that.
On Airbnb the order flips, but barely: San Isidro runs about 7.2% gross against Magdalena's roughly 7.0%. The Airbnb figure subtracts the platform fee, host-paid utilities and internet, income tax, mantenimiento, property tax and arbitrios. Note that the host pays mantenimiento on a short let, where no guest reimburses them. That is a real cost the long-term side never sees.
So the short-let comparison is close to a wash on paper, and I would not switch districts over it. The honest caveat: these are gross short-let yields, and the data we hold is thin on how consistently either district actually fills a calendar. Treat the Airbnb numbers as a ceiling, not a forecast.
For a foreign buyer who wants a tenant and a quiet life, Magdalena is the pick: higher net yield, lower entry price, and the tenant pays mantenimiento. San Isidro only makes sense if you specifically want the address and are willing to run a short let well enough to justify the extra capital. Not investment advice.