Magdalena vs Pueblo Libre: better rental investment? (2026)
n = 788 Airbnb listings · 573 sale listings · source: urbania.pe + airroi · as of 2026-11-15 · methodology →
Magdalena edges it on the numbers, but not by enough to make the decision for you. Long-term net yield is about 5.1% there against roughly 4.8% in Pueblo Libre, and on Airbnb the gross figure runs near 7.0% against about 6.8%. Those are close enough that the yield table is not where this gets settled.
The long-term figure is net of property tax, arbitrios, rental income tax and a 3% vacancy allowance; the tenant pays mantenimiento in a Lima long-term let, so that does not come off. The Airbnb figure subtracts the platform fee, host-paid utilities and internet, income tax, mantenimiento, property tax and arbitrios. Both assume you self-manage, and neither accounts for furnishing or fit-out, cleaning and turnover, or a management fee. So the Airbnb side is the more work by a wide margin for a gross number that is only marginally higher.
What actually separates them is the entry price. Magdalena sells at a median of about $2,146 per m2, Pueblo Libre at roughly $1,798. Per square metre Pueblo Libre is about 15.9% cheaper, or some $345 less. On a 70 m2 flat that is a real difference in what you wire, and it is the one gap here that is not noise.
My pick is Pueblo Libre, and I will say the uncomfortable half: you give up the slightly better yield and the slightly better Airbnb gross, and you take the cheaper entry and, in my reading of the market, the easier resale to a local buyer rather than a foreign one. Magdalena's premium buys you a district that prices higher; whether it earns that back is not something these figures prove.
Caveat: these are approximate, held steady between real moves, and the tables on the page may show a slightly different exact value. The long-term yields sit within 0.3 points of each other, which is too close to call on the headline alone. Decide on price, liquidity and how much Airbnb work you will actually do. Not investment advice.