Barranco vs San Isidro: better rental investment? (2026)
n = 2,312 Airbnb listings · 1,516 sale listings · source: urbania.pe + airroi · as of 2026-11-15 · methodology →
Barranco edges San Isidro on long-term net yield, about 4.7% against roughly 4.4%, and that is close enough that I would not buy either one on the headline number. The long-term figure subtracts property tax, arbitrios, rental income tax and a 3% vacancy allowance; the tenant pays mantenimiento in a Lima long-term let, so the landlord does not. You self-manage, so no management fee comes off. What you are really choosing between is price, liquidity and Airbnb upside.
On price San Isidro is the cheaper entry: a median of about $2,510 per m2 against Barranco's roughly $2,620, which the page puts at about 2.8% less per m2, or about $74 per m2. On a representative 70 m2 flat that is roughly $175,730 in San Isidro against about $183,540 in Barranco. You pay more per square metre for the slightly better long-term yield, and the gap in yield is thin enough that the extra money is not obviously buying you anything.
Airbnb is where San Isidro actually pulls ahead: about 7.2% gross against Barranco's roughly 6.5%. The Airbnb figure subtracts the platform fee, host-paid utilities and internet, income tax, mantenimiento (the host pays it here, since no guest reimburses them), property tax and arbitrios. Note that is gross, before furnishing and turnover, and you run it yourself. Barranco's short-let reputation is real, but the numbers here do not back it as the stronger short-let play.
So my pick is San Isidro, on the uncomfortable logic that the long-term yields are too close to separate and San Isidro wins on the two things that are not a coin flip: you pay less per square metre, and the Airbnb gross is well ahead. Barranco only makes sense if you are buying the neighbourhood for its own sake and expect the short-let to outperform what these figures show, which is a bet, not a number.
One caveat: these are approximations held steady between real moves, and the tables on the page may show slightly different exact values. The long-term yields sit within a fraction of a point, so treat the ranking as a lean rather than a verdict. Not investment advice.